Christian Dating Advice That Actually Works: 7 Mistakes You're Making (and How to Fix Them)

Dating as a Christian can feel like trying to solve a Rubik's cube blindfolded while riding a unicycle. You know there's a right way to do it, but somehow every move seems to make things more complicated. If you've ever wondered why your dating life feels more like a series of awkward coffee dates that go nowhere, you're not alone.

After years of counseling singles and married couples, I've noticed the same patterns showing up again and again. Good people with great hearts making the same dating mistakes: and wondering why they keep getting stuck in the same frustrating cycles.

The good news? Most of these mistakes are totally fixable once you know what to look for.

Mistake #1: Playing Hide and Seek With Your Dating Life

Here's the thing nobody talks about: isolation kills relationships before they even get started. When you keep your dating relationship locked away from friends, family, and mentors, you're basically creating a greenhouse for poor decisions.

Think about it. When was the last time you made your best choices when nobody was watching? Exactly.

The Fix: Bring your dating relationship into the light. Introduce your person to your friends, family, and that one brutally honest friend who will tell you if someone's not right for you. Don't withdraw from your community: invite them in. The people who know you best, love you most, and aren't afraid to tell you when you're being ridiculous are your secret weapon in dating well.

Your real friends aren't trying to sabotage your love life; they're trying to protect your heart and help you see clearly when emotions start clouding your judgment.

Mistake #2: Making Dating Your New Religion

When finding "the one" becomes more important than following The One, you've got your priorities backwards. I've watched too many amazing people become exhausted, anxious, and spiritually dry because they've made dating their primary focus.

The Fix: Keep Jesus at the center, not your relationship status. Your worth isn't determined by whether you're single or taken. Before you worry about guarding your heart in dating, make sure your heart belongs fully to Christ first.

Start each day with prayer, stay connected to God's word, and remember that your identity comes from being a child of God: not from being someone's boyfriend or girlfriend. When your foundation is solid, everything else falls into place more naturally.

Mistake #3: Becoming Joined at the Hip (Too Soon)

Spending every free moment together might feel romantic, but it's actually a red flag wearing a disguise. When you're together four or five nights a week right from the start, you're not dating: you're playing house without the commitment.

The Fix: Maintain balance. Keep your friendships, hobbies, and personal time sacred. A healthy relationship adds to your life; it doesn't consume it.

Set boundaries around time together. If you can't enjoy a weekend apart without feeling anxious, that's not love: that's dependency. Real love gives the other person space to grow and maintains other meaningful relationships.

Mistake #4: Confusing Emotional Intimacy With a Green Light

Sharing your deepest secrets and childhood traumas on date three isn't vulnerability: it's emotional fast-forwarding. When you dump your entire life story on someone before you even know if they're trustworthy, you're setting yourself up for heartbreak.

The Fix: Let intimacy develop naturally. Share personal things gradually as trust is built over time. There's a difference between being open and being unwise.

Ask yourself: "Has this person earned the right to know this about me?" Trust is built through consistency over time, not through deep conversations over dinner.

Mistake #5: Playing Games Instead of Being Real

If you're still trying to decode what "Hey" means at 11 PM or wondering if waiting three days to text back makes you seem more desirable, you're playing games instead of building a relationship.

The Fix: Be direct about your intentions. A person worth dating will appreciate honesty over games. If you're interested, show it. If you're not, be kind but clear.

Stop waiting for the other person to make the first move if you're interested. Stop sending mixed signals if you're not. Your time is valuable, and so is theirs.

Mistake #6: Dating Without a Purpose

"I just want someone to love me" is not a dating strategy: it's a recipe for settling for the wrong person. When you don't know what you're looking for, you'll end up with whatever shows up.

The Fix: Know what you're looking for before you start looking. What kind of character do you want in a spouse? How do they treat service workers? How do they handle conflict? Do they have a growing relationship with Jesus?

Stop dating people for their potential and start dating them for who they are right now. You're not a rehabilitation center, and you can't love someone into becoming who you want them to be.

Mistake #7: Forgetting That You're Human (And So Are They)

Here's the truth nobody wants to admit: you're going to mess up. You'll say the wrong thing, misunderstand each other, and disappoint one another. Instead of pretending you've got it all figured out, learn how to navigate the inevitable bumps together.

The Fix: Make relying on Jesus your first response, not your last resort. When conflicts arise (and they will), turn to prayer, wise counsel, and grace. Learn how to apologize well, forgive quickly, and grow together.

Remember that you're both works in progress. The goal isn't perfection: it's growing closer to Christ together.

The Bottom Line on Christian Dating Advice

Dating well isn't about following a perfect formula: it's about keeping Christ at the center, being intentional about your choices, and surrounding yourself with people who will speak truth into your life.

Stop trying to guard your heart by building walls, and start guarding it by making wise choices. You deserve to be loved well, but that starts with loving yourself well and understanding your worth comes from Christ, not from your relationship status.

The right person will appreciate your standards, respect your boundaries, and encourage your relationship with Jesus. Don't settle for less.

If you're feeling stuck in dating patterns that aren't working or need guidance on building healthy relationships, you don't have to figure it out alone. Professional Christian counseling can provide the tools and perspective you need to break unhealthy cycles and build the relationship skills that last.

Ready to stop making the same dating mistakes and start building relationships that honor God? Visit laynemcdonald.com to discover resources, coaching, and support that can help you navigate dating with confidence and purpose. Your future self (and your future spouse) will thank you.