The Idol of Comfort: Why We Get Mad When Church Stops Entertaining Us

Something fascinating happens when churches dial back the production value. People don't just notice: they get upset. Really upset. And that reaction reveals something uncomfortable about what we've turned church into.

I've watched congregations split over worship style changes, seen families leave because the new pastor preaches longer sermons, and heard complaints that services have become "too heavy" or "not fun anymore." What's really being said? "Church stopped entertaining me, and I don't like it."

When Comfort Becomes Our God

Here's the truth we need to face: somewhere along the way, many of us made comfort our deity. We didn't mean to: it happened gradually, subtly, like most idolatry does. We started expecting church to make us feel good rather than help us grow good.

Consumer Christianity has trained us to evaluate worship like we're reviewing a restaurant. Was the music polished? Did the sermon inspire without challenging? Did I leave feeling better about myself? These aren't necessarily wrong questions, but when they become our primary filters for spiritual engagement, we've missed the point entirely.

The idol of comfort whispers convincing lies: "God wants you happy." "Faith should feel easy." "If it makes you uncomfortable, it's probably not from God." But comfort was never meant to be our compass: transformation was.

Romans 12:1-2 paints a radically different picture: "Therefore, I urge you, brothers and sisters, in view of God's mercy, to offer your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God: this is your true and proper worship. Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind."

Notice what's missing from Paul's description of worship? Entertainment. Comfort. Easy feelings. Instead, he talks about sacrifice, transformation, and mind renewal: none of which sound particularly comfortable.

The Performance Trap

Churches have spent decades creating elaborate productions to fill pews. Professional musicians, dynamic lighting, carefully crafted sermon series with matching graphics and promotional campaigns. Not all of this is wrong: excellence in ministry can honor God. But when the production becomes the point, we've created a dangerous expectation.

Entertainment has become so embedded in evangelical culture that many can't imagine worship without it. We've conditioned people to associate spiritual engagement with professional-quality performance, and when that's removed, it feels like something sacred has been lost.

But here's what actually happened: we confused the wrapping with the gift. The elaborate presentation became more important than the presence of God. The show became more valued than the Spirit.

Conviction Isn't Condemnation

When churches shift from entertainment to formation, people often experience something unfamiliar: conviction. Not condemnation: that's different entirely. Conviction says, "You're loved enough to be challenged." Condemnation says, "You're not good enough to be loved."

Conviction makes us squirm because it reveals gaps between who we are and who God calls us to be. It's uncomfortable by design: comfort doesn't produce growth. As Jesus said in Luke 9:23, "Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me."

That word "deny" doesn't mean "treat yourself to something nice." Taking up a cross isn't a metaphor for mild inconvenience. Jesus was talking about death to our comfort-seeking selves so we could live for something greater.

But we've sanitized discipleship into a comfort-preserving lifestyle choice rather than a life-transforming commitment. When churches call us back to authentic discipleship, we react like our comfort god is under attack: because it is.

The Great Question Shift

Consumer Christianity asks the wrong question: "What did I get out of church today?" This question turns worship into a transaction where we show up expecting to receive value for our time investment. When the value doesn't meet our expectations, we shop elsewhere.

Formation-focused faith asks a better question: "Who did I become through worship today?" This question recognizes that church isn't about us getting something: it's about us being transformed into something.

James 1:22 captures this perfectly: "Do not merely listen to the word, and so deceive yourselves. Do what it says." The goal isn't information consumption; it's character formation. We don't come to church to be entertained; we come to be equipped, challenged, and changed.

When we shift our question from "What did I get?" to "Who am I becoming?" everything changes. Suddenly, a challenging sermon isn't boring: it's growth. A call to deeper commitment isn't burdensome: it's purpose. Opportunities to serve aren't interruptions: they're invitations to transformation.

Breaking Free from Consumer Faith

So how do we break free from the comfort idol? How do we recalibrate our expectations and reorient our hearts toward authentic discipleship?

Start with honest self-examination. What are you really looking for when you come to church? Entertainment? Inspiration? Challenge? Community? Growth? There's nothing wrong with wanting to be inspired or built up, but if that's your primary motivation, you might be treating church like a spiritual vending machine.

Embrace the discomfort of conviction. When something in a sermon or worship song makes you uncomfortable, don't immediately dismiss it. Sit with it. Pray about it. Ask God if He's trying to show you something. Comfort rarely leads to growth, but conviction often does.

Redefine "good church." Stop measuring church by how it made you feel and start measuring it by how it formed you. Did you leave more in love with Jesus? More committed to His mission? More aware of areas where you need to grow? These are better metrics than whether the music was your style or the sermon was the right length.

The Hidden Service Challenge

Here's a practical step that will revolutionize your relationship with church: commit to serving one Sunday a month in a "hidden" role where nobody applauds. Clean bathrooms. Set up chairs. Fold bulletins. Serve in the nursery during the service you usually attend.

Why? Because consumer Christians don't usually volunteer for invisible work. But disciples do. When you serve behind the scenes, you stop being an audience member and become a participant in God's work. You stop asking what you're getting and start focusing on what you're giving.

This isn't about earning God's favor: that's already yours through Christ. It's about aligning your heart with His mission and breaking free from the consumer mindset that treats church like a service provider.

The Path Forward

Churches need to lead this transformation, but members can embrace it too. We can choose formation over entertainment. We can value conviction over comfort. We can measure spiritual growth by character development rather than emotional satisfaction.

This doesn't mean church should be boring or cold. Joy, celebration, and beauty all have their place in worship. But they shouldn't be the point: they should be the overflow of hearts genuinely encountering God and being transformed by Him.

The goal isn't to make church miserable: it's to make church meaningful. When we stop worshipping our comfort and start embracing our calling, everything changes. We become the people God designed us to be, and church becomes what God intended it to be: not an entertainment venue, but a transformation space.

The question isn't whether you'll be comfortable in this kind of church. The question is: who will you become?

---

Ready to break free from consumer faith and embrace transformational discipleship? Dr. Layne McDonald's coaching and resources can help you develop authentic spiritual maturity that goes beyond Sunday entertainment. Visit our leadership page to discover practical tools for deepening your faith and becoming the disciple God designed you to be.