Are You Making These 7 Common 'Guard Your Heart' Mistakes? (And How to Fix Them)

Picture this: You're at your family's Christmas gathering, and Aunt Martha corners you by the eggnog station. "So, are you dating anyone special?" she asks with that look that says she's already planning your wedding. Meanwhile, your heart feels like it's been through a theological blender, and you're wondering if you're even "guarding" it correctly.

If you've ever felt confused about what it actually means to guard your heart, especially during the season when romance feels extra magical with all those Christmas lights and mistletoe, you're not alone. The truth is, most of us are making some pretty common mistakes that leave our hearts either over-protected or under-protected.

Proverbs 4:23 tells us to "guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it." But here's what Solomon didn't mention: there's a wrong way to do it that can actually make things worse.

Mistake #1: Building Fort Knox Instead of Healthy Boundaries

The biggest mistake? Thinking that guarding your heart means building an emotional fortress that nobody can penetrate. You know the type, they've been hurt before, so now they approach dating like they're interviewing for a CIA position. Every conversation feels like an interrogation, and vulnerability is treated like classified information.

Here's the thing: God didn't design your heart to be a bunker. He designed it to love and be loved. The goal isn't to become emotionally unavailable; it's to become emotionally wise.

The Fix: Instead of walls, build healthy boundaries. Think of it like Christmas light safety, you don't avoid decorating your house because there's a risk of electrical issues. You just make sure your wiring is safe and you don't overload the circuits.

Mistake #2: Avoiding All Emotional Vulnerability (The Grinch Approach)

Some people guard their hearts by simply... not feeling anything. They've essentially become the Grinch of dating, their hearts are three sizes too small, and they avoid anything that might require genuine emotional connection.

This shows up in relationships as keeping everything surface-level, avoiding deep conversations, or bailing the moment things start to feel "too real." But here's what's wild: even the Grinch's heart grew when he opened himself up to love.

The Fix: Vulnerability isn't the enemy, reckless vulnerability is. Share your heart gradually and with wisdom, like unwrapping presents on Christmas morning rather than tearing through everything at once.

Mistake #3: Ignoring Red Flags Because of Holiday Loneliness

Christmas amplifies everything, including loneliness. Suddenly, having someone to bring to your office Christmas party feels more important than whether they actually share your values. You start overlooking red flags because, hey, at least you won't have to sit alone during the family prayer at Christmas dinner.

This is like accepting a beautifully wrapped present without checking what's actually inside. Just because something looks good under the Christmas tree doesn't mean it's what you really want.

The Fix: Make a list of your non-negotiables before the holiday emotions hit. Write them down when you're thinking clearly, not when you're watching romantic Christmas movies and feeling sorry for yourself.

Mistake #4: Confusing Physical Attraction with Spiritual Connection

Just because someone looks like they could star in a Hallmark Christmas movie doesn't mean they're your person. Physical attraction is important, but it's not the foundation of a godly relationship. Too many people mistake butterflies for the Holy Spirit's guidance.

Think of it this way: Christmas decorations are beautiful, but they're not the house. Don't build your relationship on the decorations alone.

The Fix: Ask yourself: "Do I admire their character as much as their smile? Would I respect their decisions if they weren't attractive to me?" If the answer is no, pump the brakes.

Mistake #5: Flying Solo (No Accountability Partners)

One of the biggest mistakes in guarding your heart is thinking you can do it alone. You wouldn't hang Christmas lights on a steep roof without someone spotting you, so why would you navigate relationships without trusted advisors?

Too many people keep their dating life completely separate from their spiritual community, which is like trying to decorate a Christmas tree while wearing a blindfold. You need people who love you enough to tell you when you're about to make a questionable choice.

The Fix: Involve your trusted friends and mentors in your dating journey. Let them meet the people you're interested in. Ask for their honest feedback and actually listen to it: especially when it's not what you want to hear.

Mistake #6: Holiday Emotional Decisions

There's something about Christmas music, twinkling lights, and the general magic of the season that makes people want to make big emotional decisions. Suddenly, that person you've been casually dating seems like "the one," or you're ready to define the relationship because you want someone to kiss at midnight on New Year's.

Emotions run high during the holidays, and that's not necessarily the best time to make major relationship decisions. It's like shopping for Christmas gifts on Christmas Eve: you're probably going to make some choices you'll regret later.

The Fix: Give yourself a 30-day cooling-off period before making any major relationship decisions during the holiday season. If you still feel the same way in January, then you might be onto something.

Mistake #7: Guarding Your Heart FROM Jesus Instead of WITH Him

Here's the biggest mistake of all: thinking you need to protect your heart from God's involvement in your love life. Some people compartmentalize their dating life so completely that they forget to actually involve Jesus in their relationships.

You pray about your career, your finances, your family: but when it comes to your heart, suddenly you think you've got it handled? That's like trying to celebrate Christmas without acknowledging what Christmas is actually about.

The Fix: Instead of guarding your heart from God, guard it with God. Involve Him in every step. Pray about your relationships. Ask for wisdom. Trust His timing, even when it doesn't align with your holiday timeline.

Three Practical Family Tips for the Holiday Season

Since we're talking about guarding hearts during Christmas, here are some practical tips for families navigating these conversations:

1. Create a "No Dating Interrogation" Zone: Agree as a family that holiday gatherings are for celebration, not relationship status updates. Give your single family members the gift of enjoying Christmas without constant questions about their love life.

2. Model Healthy Relationships: Married couples and dating couples in the family can model what healthy boundaries and godly relationships look like, especially during stressful holiday planning.

3. Pray Together: Include prayers for wisdom in relationships during your family devotions. Let your single family members know they're covered in prayer, not judgment.

The Heart of the Matter

Guarding your heart isn't about becoming emotionally unavailable or creating impossibly high standards that no human could meet. It's about stewarding the gift God gave you: your capacity to love and be loved: with wisdom, intentionality, and faith.

This Christmas season, instead of letting holiday emotions drive your relationship decisions, remember that the same God who sent Jesus as the ultimate expression of love wants good things for your heart too. He's not trying to keep you from love; He's trying to lead you to the kind of love that lasts beyond the holiday magic.

Your heart is worth guarding, not because love is dangerous, but because love is precious. Don't let past hurts turn you into the Grinch, and don't let holiday loneliness make you settle for less than God's best.

The greatest love story ever told started with God loving us enough to send His Son. Trust that same love to guide your story too.

---

Ready to dive deeper into building healthy, God-centered relationships? Whether you're navigating the dating world or helping others do the same, I'd love to connect with you. Visit laynemcdonald.com for relationship coaching resources, or if you're looking for a faith community to support your journey, connect with us at famemphis.org/connect. Because the best relationships: romantic or otherwise: happen in community, with wisdom, and with God at the center.