[Family and Parenting]: Looking for a Safe Church? 10 Red Flags Every Christian Parent Should Know

Choosing a church for your family is one of the most significant decisions you will ever make. It isn't just about finding a place where the worship music resonates or the coffee is hot. For parents, it is about finding a community that will partner with you in the spiritual formation of your children while keeping them physically, emotionally, and spiritually safe.

In our desire to find a spiritual home, we often fall victim to the "halo effect." We assume that because a building has a cross on it and the people use the right vocabulary, everyone inside is safe. But we live in a fallen world, and sometimes the very places meant to be sanctuaries can become environments where safety is compromised due to negligence or lack of accountability.

I’ve spent years looking at how ministry structures impact families. Protecting our kids requires us to look past the Sunday morning production and peek under the hood. Here are ten red flags every Christian parent should know when evaluating a church’s safety.

1. Inadequate Volunteer Screening

This is the most fundamental baseline for safety. If a church allows a volunteer to work with children on their first visit without a background check, that is a massive red flag. A safe church should have a rigorous "waiting period" for new members before they can volunteer, alongside mandatory background checks and Working With Children Checks.

I often tell parents: don’t be afraid to ask to see the policy. If the church leadership is offended that you’re asking about their screening process, that in itself is a warning sign. Healthy organizations love it when parents care about safety.

2. Private, Unmonitored Spaces

Architecture and classroom design play a huge role in safety. There should never be a location: whether it’s a classroom, an office, or a storage closet: where an outside observer cannot see what is happening.

Look for windows in every door. If a door doesn't have a window, it should be kept open at all times. If you see adults taking children into private rooms or "quiet corners" that are hidden from public view, you are looking at a system that allows abusers to operate in secret. Transparency is the best deterrent.

3. Missing or Confusing Safety Policies

Every church should have a written Child Safety Policy (CSP). This shouldn't just be a dusty binder in the pastor’s office; it should be a living document that parents can access easily.

Does the policy cover check-in and check-out procedures? Does it define the "two-adult rule" (where no adult is ever alone with a child)? If a church cannot provide you with a copy of their safety protocols, or if the leadership seems confused about what those protocols are, the safety of your children is likely being left to "good intentions" rather than a system. You can see more about how healthy leadership structures should function in our guide on church leadership mistakes and how to fix them.

4. Over-Interest in Kids by Specific Adults

Abusers often "hide in plain sight" by being the "super-volunteer." They may seek out opportunities to have extended one-on-one access to children through special trips, private tutoring, or extra-curricular church events.

Watch for adults who seem to have more underage friends than adult friends. If an adult is frequently texting your child or messaging them on social media without including you in the thread, that is a boundary violation. In a safe church environment, all digital communication between staff/volunteers and minors should be transparent and inclusive of parents.

5. Defensive Responses to Concerns

How does leadership respond when a parent raises a concern? In a safe church, leaders listen, investigate, and thank the parent for being vigilant. In an unsafe church, the parent is often labeled as "divisive," "untrusting," or "attacking the Lord's anointed."

If your gut tells you something is off and you are met with hostility rather than a spirit of cooperation, the church is prioritizing its reputation over the safety of its sheep.

6. A Culture of Enforced Silence

Healthy churches thrive on transparency. If you notice that staff members seem afraid to speak up, or if there is a "culture of honor" that is actually just a "culture of never questioning the lead pastor," safety will eventually suffer.

When people are discouraged from asking questions about finances, doctrine, or safety, it creates a vacuum where misconduct can flourish. Accountability is not an attack; it is a biblical requirement.

7. Digital Safety and the "Screen Gap"

In 2026, safety isn't just physical: it's digital. Many youth groups use apps for communication, and children often bring their own devices to church events. Does the church have a policy on device use during lock-ins or retreats?

As parents, we also need to take the lead at home. Tools like Bark and Covenant Eyes are essential, but they serve different purposes. Bark is excellent for monitoring social media and alerting you to potential grooming or bullying, while Covenant Eyes focuses on screenshot-based accountability to prevent exposure to pornography. If you need a refresher on how to set these up, check out our quick-start guide to digital safety.

8. Excessive Reliance on Charismatic Authority

When a church revolves entirely around the personality and "vision" of one individual, the standard safety checks and balances often fail. One or two dominant leaders operating without meaningful oversight is a recipe for disaster.

If the leadership appointments lack transparency or if the decision-making process is entirely informal and "relational," there is no way to hold leaders accountable if a safety breach occurs.

9. Financial Opacity

You might wonder what money has to do with child safety. Often, it’s about the heart of the organization. Secretive financial practices usually indicate a lack of overall organizational accountability.

If a church hides where the money goes, they are likely hiding other things too: like legal settlements or "hush money" related to staff misconduct. Safe churches are open books because they have nothing to hide.

10. Lack of Resources for Pastoral Care

Safety also includes the well-being of the staff and volunteers. If the people teaching your children are constantly burnt out, unsupported, and operating under high stress, they are more likely to miss red flags or fail to follow safety protocols.

A church that disregards the mental and spiritual health of its staff is an organization that is cutting corners. Those corners often include the safety of the most vulnerable members of the congregation.

Takeaway / Next Step: Protecting the Flock

The goal of identifying these red flags isn't to make us cynical or fearful; it’s to make us wise. We are called to be as "shrewd as snakes and as innocent as doves."

Your next step is to perform a "Safety Audit" of your current church. Ask to see the Child Safety Policy this week. Observe the classroom doors. Notice if there are background checks being run on the youth volunteers. If you find gaps, don't necessarily run for the exit immediately: offer to help close them. A church that is willing to learn and grow is a church that can become a safe haven. However, if they refuse to address these critical red flags, your priority must be the safety of your children.

We are called to love like Jesus, and loving like Jesus means protecting the "little ones" with everything we have.

reach out to me on the site. visiting helps raise funds for families who lost children at no cost.

laynemcdonald.comboundlessonlinechurch.org

Need prayers? Text us day or night at 1-901-213-7341.