[Leadership]: The Ultimate Guide to Church Culture Repair: Everything You Need to Succeed

Faith and Healing

Let’s be honest: church culture is a lot like the air in a room. When it’s fresh and clean, nobody really talks about it: they just breathe and go about their business. But the moment it turns toxic, everyone starts gasping for air. People stop showing up, staff members start looking for the exits, and the mission gets buried under layers of politics and unaddressed hurt.

I have spent a lot of time looking at how churches operate, and I have realized that "culture" isn't just a buzzword. It is the invisible force that determines whether your vision will actually happen or if it will die on a spreadsheet. If you feel like your church culture is currently gasping for air, you aren’t alone. But more importantly, you aren’t stuck.

Repairing a church culture is heavy lifting, but it is some of the most rewarding work you will ever do as a leader. This guide is designed to walk you through the essential steps to move from a state of survival to a place of thriving health.

Step 1: Own the Current Reality

The hardest pill to swallow for any leader is this: the culture you currently have is the culture you have either created or allowed.

Whether you inherited a mess or accidentally let things slide over the last five years, ownership is the starting line. Until you, as the senior leader or department head, stand up and say, "This is on me," nothing will change. Why? Because if the problem is someone else's fault, the solution is also someone else's responsibility. By taking ownership, you take back the power to fix it.

Step 2: Tend to Your Own Soul

You cannot lead a healthy church if you are spiritually and emotionally bankrupt. I’ve seen so many leaders try to "fix" their staff or their volunteers while they themselves are running on empty, bitter, or burnt out.

Before you start rolling out new policies or values, take a week to retreat. Spend time in prayer and reflection. Give yourself permission to be human. Recognize that your job is to lead toward health, not perfection. If you are operating out of a place of defensiveness or exhaustion, your attempts at repair will only feel like more control to those around you.

Step 3: Identify the Gap

You can’t fix what you haven’t defined. You need to get a clear, honest picture of how the culture is currently being experienced. I recommend looking at it from three distinct angles:

1. The Visitor: What is the "vibe" when someone walks in for the first time?

2. The Long-term Attendee: What are the unwritten rules they follow?

3. The Staff/Key Leaders: What is the "real" conversation that happens after the meeting ends?

Try to identify five words that describe your current culture. Are you "defensive"? "Siloed"? "Polite but distant"? Be brutally honest. Once you have those words, compare them to where you want to be. That space in between is your "gap," and that is where your work begins.

Step 4: Identify and Eliminate Toxins

Toxic cultures don't just happen; they are fed by specific behaviors. If you want the air to get clean, you have to stop the pollution at the source. Common toxins include:

• Political Behavior: People maneuvering behind the scenes to get what they want.

• Low Morale: A general sense of "why does this matter?"

• High Defensiveness: An inability to take feedback without making excuses.

• Unresolved Conflict: Issues that have been "prayed about" but never actually dealt with.

If you recognize these, you have to call them out. If you're struggling with why your team feels disconnected, you might find some answers in my previous post on 10 reasons your church leadership team isn’t working.

Step 5: Model the Culture You Want

Culture isn't what you put on the wall; it’s what you do in the hallway. If you want a culture of radical generosity, you have to be the most generous person in the room. If you want a culture of invitation, you should be the one inviting people to lunch and into your home.

Leaders set the ceiling for the health of the organization. If you are secretive, your staff will be secretive. If you are vulnerable and admit when you’ve made a mistake, you give everyone else permission to do the same. This is about transitioning from leading programs to building a community.

Step 6: Build a Healthy Foundation

A healthy church culture is built on a few non-negotiable pillars:

• Genuine Community: We aren't just a group of people who attend the same event; we are a family following Jesus together.

• Humility: Arrogance is the fastest way to poison a culture. Lead with a towel, not a title.

• Empowerment: Give people the tools and the authority to lead. When every volunteer moment matters, people feel invested in the outcome.

Step 7: Master the Art of Healthy Conflict

Most "bad" cultures are just cultures that are afraid of conflict. When people don't know how to disagree healthily, they resort to gossip, passive-aggression, or total withdrawal.

You must train your team in how to resolve conflict the way Jesus taught us. Speak clearly, listen well, and clarify expectations. When conflict arises, remain the "calm presence" in the room. Refuse to be baited into emotional reactions and keep the focus on the mission, not the personalities involved.

Step 8: Design the Roadmap for Change

Once you know where you are and where you want to go, you need a plan. Don’t try to change everything in a week. If you try to flip a church culture overnight, you’ll likely break the very people you’re trying to lead.

Introduce new concepts gradually. Use your sermons, your staff meetings, and your volunteer huddles to repeat the new cultural values over and over again. As the saying goes, "When you are tired of saying it, they are just beginning to hear it."

Step 9: Make the Tough Decisions

This is the part that many leaders avoid. Sometimes, culture repair requires people to leave. Not everyone will want to go where you are going. Some people thrive in toxic environments because it gives them power or comfort.

If you have a staff member or a key leader who refuses to adopt the new healthy culture after repeated coaching, you have to make a choice: do you keep that person, or do you keep your healthy culture? You cannot have both. The absence of a tough decision is a decision to let things stay exactly as they are.

Step 10: Consider Outside Help

Sometimes you are too close to the situation to see the solution. There is no shame in bringing in an outside voice: a mentor or a trusted leader from another church: to give you an objective "audit" of your environment. They can often spot the "smell" of the culture that you’ve become nose-blind to.

Step 11: Commit to the Long Term

Culture is a slow-cooker, not a microwave. If your church has been unhealthy for ten years, it isn't going to be fixed in ten months. You have to be willing to stay the course through the "messy middle" where the old culture is dying but the new culture hasn't fully taken root yet. Stay committed to pouring your energy into people, not just processes.

---

Takeaway / Next Step

Identify your "Five Words." Your immediate next step is to grab a notepad and sit in a quiet place. Write down the five words that honestly describe your church culture today. Then, write down the five words you want people to use two years from now.

Pick just one of those desired words: perhaps "Trust" or "Joy": and identify one specific action you can take this week to model that word to your team. Transformation begins with a single, intentional step.

---

If you're looking for more resources on how to lead well or need guidance on your faith journey, visit boundlessonlinechurch.org or reach out to me on the site.

visiting helps raise funds for families who lost children at no cost.

Need prayers? Text us day or night at 1-901-213-7341.

www.laynemcdonald.com