[Leadership]: 10 Reasons Your Church Leadership Team Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)

Category: Faith and Healing

I've watched too many gifted leaders burn out, talented teams fall apart, and vibrant ministries lose momentum, all because the leadership structure wasn't built to last. If your church leadership team feels more like a burden than a blessing, you're not alone. The good news? Most leadership struggles aren't personality problems, they're structural problems. And structure can be fixed.

Let's walk through the ten most common reasons church leadership teams break down, and more importantly, how to repair them.

1. Nobody Knows What They're Supposed to Do

Here's a scenario I see all the time: someone joins the leadership team, shows up to meetings, and... nobody's really sure what they're responsible for. Roles are vague. Expectations are unclear. And when things go wrong, everyone points fingers.

The Fix: Write it down. Document every leadership role with specific responsibilities, decision-making authority, and success metrics. Make sure new team members receive this in writing before their first meeting. Clarity isn't controlling, it's caring enough to set people up for success.

2. Communication Is Broken (Or Non-Existent)

Most church leadership problems trace back to communication failures. Leaders don't listen. Team members feel unheard. Important decisions happen in parking lot conversations instead of structured meetings. When people don't feel valued enough to be kept in the loop, they disengage fast.

The Fix: Create formal communication rhythms. Weekly check-ins. Monthly team meetings. Quarterly vision-casting sessions. But here's the key, make them two-way conversations. Ask questions. Invite feedback. Actually listen to concerns instead of dismissing them. Your team doesn't need a megaphone; they need a dialogue.

3. Your Organizational Structure Is a Mess

When there's no clear structure for how decisions get made, who reports to whom, and how ministries connect, chaos fills the void. People work in silos. Duplicate efforts waste resources. And nobody's quite sure who's steering the ship.

The Fix: Map out your organizational chart. Consider a shared-authority model where pairs or small groups make decisions together instead of relying on one person to carry everything. Create policies collaboratively with the people who'll have to live by them. Structure doesn't kill creativity, it protects it.

4. You're Doing Everything Yourself

I get it. Sometimes it feels faster to just do it yourself than to train someone else. But when you're functioning as pastor, teacher, strategist, project manager, counselor, and janitor all at once, you're not leading, you're drowning.

The Fix: Learn to delegate effectively. This isn't about dumping tasks on people; it's about empowering them to lead. Give team members real authority, not just grunt work. Provide the training and tools they need. Then step back and let them run with it. Yes, they might do it differently than you would. That's the point.

5. New Leaders Get Thrown Into the Deep End

Someone agrees to join leadership, shows up to their first meeting, and realizes they have no idea how things work, what the culture is, or what's expected of them. They spend months feeling lost before they either figure it out or quit.

The Fix: Build a real onboarding process. Assign new leaders a mentor. Walk them through your church's history, values, and vision. Explain how decisions get made and where they fit in. Give them time to observe before expecting them to produce. Proper onboarding turns overwhelmed newcomers into confident contributors.

6. You're Micromanaging Everything

When leaders hover over every decision, second-guess every choice, and require approval for every minor detail, team members stop trying. Why invest creativity and effort when you know the boss will just override you anyway?

The Fix: Build a culture of trust and accountability. Define the outcomes you want, then let people figure out how to get there. Focus on results, not processes. Yes, people will make mistakes. That's called learning. Your job isn't to prevent all errors: it's to create an environment where people can grow through them.

7. Leadership Transitions Are Painful

Someone steps down from leadership, and the whole team scrambles. Nobody was prepared. Institutional knowledge walks out the door. The congregation is confused. And the new leader starts from scratch.

The Fix: Plan transitions well in advance. Communicate early and often. Document processes so knowledge doesn't leave when people do. Create overlap periods where outgoing and incoming leaders work together. Celebrate departing leaders publicly and honor their contributions. Transitions don't have to be traumatic.

8. You're Stuck in "We've Always Done It This Way"

Rigid leaders who refuse to adapt kill teams. When someone suggests a new approach and gets shot down because "that's not how we do things here," innovation dies. Eventually, your best people leave to find environments where their ideas matter.

The Fix: Cultivate flexibility. Ask "what if?" questions. Listen to perspectives different from your own. Acknowledge that methods that worked ten years ago might not work today. Being faithful to the mission doesn't mean being married to outdated methods. Stay grounded in truth while remaining open to change.

9. Your Leaders Are Burned Out

When leaders are exhausted, stressed, and running on empty, they have nothing left to give. The emotional and spiritual work of leadership requires energy: energy that disappears when someone's carrying too much for too long.

The Fix: Redistribute responsibilities. Stop expecting leaders to do everything. Share authority across teams instead of concentrating it in a few people. Ask your team members how you can pray for them. Check in on their spiritual health, not just their task completion. Model Sabbath rest. Burned-out leaders can't build healthy churches.

10. There's No Real Accountability

Without accountability, teams drift. People say one thing and do another. Conflicts go unaddressed. And toxic behaviors get excused because "they've been here forever" or "we don't want to cause problems."

The Fix: Create clear accountability systems. Define expectations. Provide regular feedback. Address conflicts directly and quickly. If someone refuses to reconcile or consistently acts against team values, have the courage to ask them to step down. Protecting team health sometimes means making hard decisions. Unity doesn't mean avoiding difficult conversations: it means having them with grace and truth.

Building Leadership That Lasts

Fixing a broken leadership team isn't easy. It requires honest evaluation, difficult conversations, and sustained commitment to change. But it's worth it.

Strong leadership teams don't happen by accident. They're built through intentional structure, clear communication, healthy culture, and leaders who care more about empowering others than protecting their own position.

Your church deserves leadership that works. Your team deserves to operate in an environment where they can thrive. And the people you're called to serve deserve leaders who are healthy, aligned, and equipped to guide them well.

The question isn't whether your team is perfect: no team is. The question is whether you're willing to do the work to make it better.

---

Ready to Build Stronger Leadership?

If you're working to repair church culture, develop healthier teams, or grow as a leader, I'd love to help. Check out more resources and insights at laynemcdonald.com and connect with our community at boundlessonlinechurch.org. Your visit helps: visiting helps raise funds for families who lost children at no cost.

Need prayers? Text us day or night at 1-901-213-7341.

Every leader faces challenges. The best ones? They ask for help. reach out to me on the site.