Book: Peace of the Presence – Chapter 4: Christian Nationalism Explained: 5 Steps How to Discern Culture and Defend the Gospel
- Dr. Layne McDonald
- Jul 9
- 8 min read
"Jesus said, 'My kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would fight to prevent my arrest by the Jewish leaders. But now my kingdom is from another place.'" : John 18:36 (NIV)
The air in the room was thick with a kind of electricity that had nothing to do with lighting and everything to do with tension. I was sitting in a coffee shop, watching two friends: both followers of Jesus: debate a news cycle that had set the internet on fire that morning. One was leaning forward, voice rising, quoting historical figures as if they were apostles. The other was shaking his head, his face a mask of weary frustration.
They weren't talking about the Gospel. They weren't talking about the beauty of the Cross or the power of the Holy Spirit. They were arguing about the soul of a nation, but in a way that made it clear they believed that soul could only be saved through the ballot box and the seizure of cultural power.
In that moment, I realized that the "digital storm" I had been documenting in the first three chapters of Peace of the Presence had claimed another victim: the interior peace of the believer. When our primary identity shifts from being citizens of the Kingdom of Heaven to being warriors for an earthly state, the "Peace that surpasses all understanding" is the first thing we lose.
This chapter is about a phenomenon that is currently shaking the American Church to its core: Christian Nationalism. But this isn't a political lecture. This is a survival guide for your soul. We are going to explain what it is, why it is dangerous to your spiritual health, and provide a 5-step framework for biblically grounded cultural discernment so you can defend the Gospel while keeping your heart anchored in the presence of God.
The Anatomy of the Political Spirit
For years, we have been told that we are in a culture war. And while it is true that biblical values are often at odds with secular trends, the way we fight that "war" matters more than we realize. In my previous book, Sheep No More, I documented the "Machine": the sophisticated media and political systems designed to manufacture outrage and tribal certainty for profit.
The Machine has found its most potent fuel in the fusion of faith and national identity.
Christian Nationalism is not the same thing as patriotism. Patriotism is a healthy love for one’s country: a gratitude for the blessings of where you live and a desire to see it flourish. Christian Nationalism, however, is a political ideology that seeks to merge Christian and national identities, suggesting that to be a "real" American is to be a "certain kind" of Christian, and that the government’s primary duty is to enforce that identity through state power.
As an Assemblies of God-aligned ministry, we must be clear: our mandate is the Great Commission, not a Great Capture. When we confuse the Kingdom of God with the Kingdom of Man, we don't just lose our political influence; we lose our witness. We lose the "Peace of the Presence" because we have traded the Holy Spirit for the Political Spirit.
Why Christian Nationalism Distorts the Gospel
The danger of Christian Nationalism is not just political; it is theological. It shifts the center of gravity in the believer’s life. Instead of looking to the Cross as the ultimate symbol of power-through-sacrifice, it looks to the Capitol as the ultimate symbol of power-through-coercion.
1. It Misreads the Nature of the Kingdom
Jesus stood before Pilate: the representative of the greatest empire on earth: and said, "My kingdom is not of this world." If Jesus wanted to "take back" a nation, He would have started with Rome. Instead, He started with a towel and a basin, washing feet. Christian Nationalism often seeks to use the tools of the world (coercion, legal force, and exclusion) to accomplish the goals of the Spirit (transformation, love, and inclusion).
2. It Creates a "New Israel" Complex
One of the core tenets of this ideology is the belief that America (or any modern nation-state) has a special covenantal relationship with God, similar to ancient Israel. But the New Testament is clear: the "holy nation" is the Church: the multi-ethnic, global body of believers (1 Peter 2:9). When we apply Old Testament promises meant for Israel directly to a modern secular nation without theological nuance, we risk falling into a form of nationalistic idolatry.
3. It Substitutes Fear for Faith
The Machine survives on fear. It tells you that if "they" win, God loses. It tells you that the Church is one election away from extinction. This is a lie. The Church has survived Mao, Stalin, and Nero. The Church thrived in the catacombs. When we lean into Christian Nationalism, we are essentially saying that God’s sovereignty is dependent on the Supreme Court. That is not faith; that is anxiety masked as activism.
5 Steps to Discern Culture and Defend the Gospel
How do we navigate this? How do we live as responsible citizens who love our neighbors and vote our values, without losing ourselves in the tribalism of the day? We use a framework of biblical discernment.
Step 1: Identify the Center (Nation vs. Christ)
The first step is a heart audit. Ask yourself: Is my primary sense of hope found in the progress of my country or the progress of the Gospel? If you find yourself more grieved by a political loss than by the fact that your neighbor doesn't know Jesus, your center has shifted. The Gospel must remain the "Sun" of your solar system; the nation is merely a planet orbiting it.
Step 2: Conduct an Identity Audit (Christian vs. American)
We are citizens of two kingdoms, but our allegiances are not equal. Philippians 3:20 tells us, "Our citizenship is in heaven." This means that our primary identity is "Follower of Jesus." Our secondary identity is "Citizen of [Your Country]." When the values of our country (or our political party) conflict with the values of the Sermon on the Mount, the Sermon on the Mount must win every time.
Step 3: Perform a Power Check (State vs. Spirit)
How do you believe change happens? Christian Nationalism relies on the "Top-Down" power of the state. The Gospel relies on the "Bottom-Up" power of the Holy Spirit. If your strategy for changing the culture involves more lobbying than praying, or more arguing than serving, you are leaning into the wrong power source. We defend the Gospel by living it, not just by legislating its shadows.
Step 4: Validate with Text Integrity (Scripture vs. Soundbite)
One of the great casualties of the digital storm is the "Proof-Text." We see verses like 2 Chronicles 7:14 ripped out of their historical context and applied to modern political rallies. Discernment requires us to read the Bible as a whole. Does your political stance align with the entire counsel of God, including the commands to love our enemies and care for the stranger? If it only aligns with the verses that make your "team" look good, it’s not biblical discernment: it’s confirmation bias.
Step 5: Evaluate through Virtue (Love vs. Militarism)
Finally, look at the fruit. Galatians 5:22-23 lists the fruit of the Spirit: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Christian Nationalism often produces the opposite: anger, division, anxiety, and a militarized rhetoric that views political opponents as "enemies of God." If an ideology requires you to stop loving your neighbor in order to "save" your country, it is not from God.
Finding Stillness in the Midst of the Storm
The goal of this book series, Peace of the Presence, is to help you find that "still small voice" even when the world is screaming. You cannot find peace if you are constantly plugging into the outrage cycle.
I want to challenge you to do something counter-cultural. For the next week, I want you to spend more time reading the Gospels than you do reading political news. I want you to spend more time in morning prayer than you do in political debate.
When you sit in the presence of God, the "life-or-death" importance of the latest cultural controversy begins to shrink. You realize that kings come and go, empires rise and fall, but the Word of the Lord endures forever. You begin to see people not as "red" or "blue," but as souls made in the image of God who are desperately in need of the same grace that saved you.
This is how we defend the Gospel. We defend it by being the most peaceful, most loving, most courageous people in the room. We defend it by refusing to be manipulated by the Machine. We defend it by keeping our hearts anchored in the Sanctuary, even when the rest of the world is screaming in the Stadium.
The Hidden Need Underneath the Noise
Why do people cling to Christian Nationalism? Underneath the flags and the rhetoric, there is a very human need: the need for belonging and the need for security. People are scared. They feel the world changing at a dizzying pace, and they are looking for something solid to hold onto.
The tragedy is that the "nation" is a shifting sand. Governments fail. Economies fluctuate. Identities based on earthly borders will eventually dissolve.
Our job as followers of Jesus is to point people to the only thing that is truly solid: the Person of Jesus Christ. When we offer people a "Christianized" version of nationalism, we are giving them a counterfeit. We are giving them a stone when they asked for bread.
But when we offer them the Peace of the Presence: the reality of a God who is with them in the cell, in the hospital, and in the quiet of their own home: we are giving them the only thing that can actually heal the anxiety of our age.
Practical Steps for the Way of the Word
How do we walk this out on Monday morning?
Muzzle the Machine: Unfollow the accounts that thrive on partisan rage. If a "Christian" influencer makes you feel more angry at your neighbor than in love with Jesus, they are not helping your soul.
Citizen Service: Find a way to serve your local community that has nothing to do with politics. Volunteer at a food bank, mentor a student, or help a neighbor. Re-learn how to love people you disagree with.
Scripture First: Before you check the news in the morning, read a Psalm. Let God have the "first word" of your day. This simple habit is a powerful act of spiritual resistance.
The Peace Audit: At the end of each day, ask: Did my digital interactions today bring me closer to the Peace of God, or did they leave me more agitated? Adjust your "diet" accordingly.
The world doesn't need more "Christian warriors" who know how to win an argument. It needs more "Christian disciples" who know how to follow the Prince of Peace.
Reflection Questions
When you think about the future of your country, do you feel more "anxious" or "anchored" in God's sovereignty?
Can you identify a time when your political identity felt more important than your identity in Christ? What triggered that shift?
Which of the 5 Steps of Discernment do you find most difficult to apply in your daily life?
How does the reality of "Citizenship in Heaven" (Philippians 3:20) change the way you view those on the "other side" of the political aisle?
A Prayer for the Peace of the Presence
Heavenly Father, I confess that I have often let the noise of the world drown out the whisper of Your Spirit. I have let my heart become troubled by the kingdoms of man, forgetting that Your Kingdom is eternal and unshakable. Give me the grace to discern the culture through the lens of Your Word. Help me to love my country without making it an idol. Anchor my identity in You alone. May Your peace, which surpasses all understanding, guard my heart and my mind today. In Jesus’ name, Amen.
Layne McDonald, Ph.D., is a pastor, author, and cultural commentator dedicated to helping believers navigate the complexities of modern life with biblical wisdom and spiritual clarity. Through his "Sheep No More" trilogy and his extensive work in Christian publishing, Dr. McDonald provides practical tools for emotional healing, cultural discernment, and deep discipleship. His mission is to guide readers toward the "Peace of the Presence" in an increasingly distracted and divided world.
Support This Ministry If this resource has helped you find peace and clarity, consider partnering with us to bring biblically grounded teaching to more people. Your support allows us to continue creating high-quality books, studies, and cultural commentary. Give Here
Comments